Can I connect a midi keyboard to my Yamaha E343 keyboard ?

Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Hi ! I have a Yamaha E343 and a MidiPlus 61Origin. The midi for some reason misbehaves when connected to a sound module. The volume will suddenly drop or suddenly increase making it unstable onstage and quite frankly a nightmare. I play with a sustain pedal.

Can I instead connect the midi kb to my Yamaha does anyone know ? I'm hopeless with these things and I'm on the verge of buying a second kb. But someone has suggested this option to me.

Can anyone help me please ?

Also, is "Startone" any good as a kb make ?

Thanks
 
Last edited:

SeaGtGruff

I meant to play that note!
Moderator
Joined
Jun 6, 2014
Messages
4,113
Reaction score
1,737
Sorry, I deleted the second copy of your post thinking it was a double post, but then I realized the first copy was incomplete!

You wrote:

Hi ! I have a Yamaha E343 and a MidiPlus 61Origin. The midi for some reason misbehaves when connected to a sound module. The volume will suddenly drop or suddenly increase making it unstable onstage and quite frankly a nightmare. I play with a sustain pedal.

Can I instead connect the midi kb to my Yamaha does anyone know ? I'm hopeless with these things and I'm on verge of buying a second kb but someone suggested this to me.

Hoping for some positive answers from those who are more savvy than me !

Thanks.

If the volume fluctuates, it could be that the sound module is at fault, or it could be that the controller is sending inconsistent velocity values to the sound module. If the latter is the case, connecting the controller to your PSR-E343 probably won't help. You could try connecting the controller to your computer and using a MIDI monitor to check the note velocities while you're playing on the controller. Many DAW programs include a MIDI monitor function, or you can use a utility program such as MIDI-OX.

If a controller and a keyboard both have MIDI In/Out ports, then you can connect them directly using a standard MIDI cable-- plug one end into the MIDI Out port of the controller, and the other end into the MIDI In port of the keyboard.

If one or the other doesn't have MIDI In/Out ports-- as is the case with the PSR-E343-- you generally need a computer or other device between the controller and the keyboard, because a USB-MIDI connection often requires a driver. That isn't always the case, but it is with the PSR-E343.

So you could try connecting both the controller and the keyboard to a computer or laptop via USB cables (with the appropriate USB-MIDI drivers installed for each) and use a DAW or MIDI yoke utility to receive the MIDI coming from the controller and send it to the keyboard. If the volume still fluctuates unpredictably, then the problem is probably in the controller.
 
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Sorry, I deleted the second copy of your post thinking it was a double post, but then I realized the first copy was incomplete!

You wrote:



If the volume fluctuates, it could be that the sound module is at fault, or it could be that the controller is sending inconsistent velocity values to the sound module. If the latter is the case, connecting the controller to your PSR-E343 probably won't help. You could try connecting the controller to your computer and using a MIDI monitor to check the note velocities while you're playing on the controller. Many DAW programs include a MIDI monitor function, or you can use a utility program such as MIDI-OX.

If a controller and a keyboard both have MIDI In/Out ports, then you can connect them directly using a standard MIDI cable-- plug one end into the MIDI Out port of the controller, and the other end into the MIDI In port of the keyboard.

If one or the other doesn't have MIDI In/Out ports-- as is the case with the PSR-E343-- you generally need a computer or other device between the controller and the keyboard, because a USB-MIDI connection often requires a driver. That isn't always the case, but it is with the PSR-E343.

So you could try connecting both the controller and the keyboard to a computer or laptop via USB cables (with the appropriate USB-MIDI drivers installed for each) and use a DAW or MIDI yoke utility to receive the MIDI coming from the controller and send it to the keyboard. If the volume still fluctuates unpredictably, then the problem is probably in the controller.

SeaGtGruff ... thanks so much for your reply. I'm thinking after all that I may buy a new kb because my Mac is old. I've been looking at StarTone kbs because I only want a second kb for playing secondary kb parts and drones, and there is one with midi available. Do you know anything about this make ? I've listened to a demo or two and the quality is good, the reviews are favorable too (all reviews are coming from the viewpoint of a beginner kb) but for a back-up kb it might do.

I can't find any info online about StarTone, though. I thought about Casio but one in my local music shop sounded bad. Any thoughts ?

Thanks for your help.

Jane
 
Last edited:

SeaGtGruff

I meant to play that note!
Moderator
Joined
Jun 6, 2014
Messages
4,113
Reaction score
1,737
I'd never heard of Startone before you mentioned them, and I'm reluctant to comment on any keyboards I'm unfamiliar with, beyond pointing out whatever information is in the manuals. The only information I could find out about them seemed to come from the Thomann mail order company (http://www.thomann.de/gb/startone.html), although I'm not sure what connection-- if any-- exists between Startone and Thomann. The manual for the Startone MK-300 is available in PDF form from Thomann's web site (https://images4.static-thomann.de/pics/atg/atgdata/document/manual/c_343081_r2_en_online.pdf), and every page of the manual has "Thomann" printed on it, as though Startone were a division of Thomann-- except the way Thomann talks about Startone seems to indicate that the two companies are unrelated as far as ownership, so perhaps Thomann has a special deal as distributers of Startone's products?

Anyway, the MK-300 looks like it might be a good buy as an inexpensive beginner's keyboard, but I don't know it sounds, as I can't find any videos that show it in action. It seems to be roughly comparable to the Yamaha PSR-E253 in terms of the number of sounds and styles, but it has twice the polyphony of the PSR-E253, it has touch sensitivity (whereas the PSR-E253 does not), it has a USB port for connecting to a computer (whereas the PSR-E253 does not), and it has a pitch bend wheel (which the PSR-E253 does not).

One thing the MK-300 doesn't have is the ability to modify its built-in sounds using MIDI Control Change commands for Attack Time, Release Time, Filter Resonance, and Filter Cutoff, which the PSR-E243 does have (although the PSR-E253 does not, since Yamaha removed the USB port on the PSR-E253). On the other hand, according to its manual the MK-300 is able to respond to MIDI Control Change commands for Portamento Time and Portamento On/Off, which the PSR-E243, PSR-E353, and PSR-E443 are not able to do, so that implies that you could use MIDI commands to get portamento effects. However, the MK-300's manual implies that it can't be put into mono mode, which is usually required for portamento, so I'm not sure whether or not the MK-300 can actually do portamento. And in any case, it doesn't matter whether the keyboard lets you modify its sounds and/or play portamento via MIDI Control Change commands if you won't be connecting it to a computer during performances.

One thing that's missing from the MK-300's manual is the list of Bank Select and Program Change values for each of its voices or sounds. You should be able to figure them out for yourself by connecting the MK-300 to a computer and monitoring its MIDI output as you scroll through each sound, but it would have been nice to have that information provided in the manual.

The good news is that Thomann says they offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, as well as free return service-- but only if you're in Germany. I don't know if you were thinking of ordering from Thomann, but if you order the Startone MK-300 and then decide you don't like it for some reason, you should be able to return it and get a refund-- although you'll have to pay for the return shipping (unless you're in Germany). It's always best to actually try a keyboard out before you decide to buy it, but if there are no stores in your area where you can "test drive" the MK-300 yourself, then making sure the vendor you order it from has a money-back guarantee is a must.

PS: As far as Casio keyboards, I have one Casio, and I do think my Yamaha keyboards sound better than my Casio-- but I have an older, inexpensive Casio model, so I doubt that it sounds as good as the newer Casio models. Casio keyboards seem to offer "more bang for your buck" compared to similar models of Yamaha keyboards, and there are some keyboard players who seem to be pretty devoted to Casio-- especially their digital pianos. But again, it's always best to actually play a given keyboard yourself before you decide whether or not to buy it.
 
Last edited:

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
14,065
Messages
86,843
Members
13,154
Latest member
mhsmith451

Latest Threads

Top