OT: Why do I hear nasty audio artifacts in the high frequencies on.mp3 files? (the PHYSICS of it all

Discussion in 'alt.steinberg.cubase' started by XODDI, Jun 21, 2010.

  1. XODDI Guest

    Member Since:
    Message Count:
    0
    Mainly on material compressed at 128.

    I do not think that it's just my ears, as other people I know have
    mentioned it.

    A point to a good article would be as good as a detailed explanation.
      • Advertising
  2. Laurence Payne Guest

    Member Since:
    Message Count:
    0
    Re: OT: Why do I hear nasty audio artifacts in the high frequencies on .mp3 files? (the PHYSICS of it all)

    On Mon, 21 Jun 2010 13:06:02 -0700 (PDT), XODDI
    <> wrote:

    >Mainly on material compressed at 128.
    >
    >I do not think that it's just my ears, as other people I know have
    >mentioned it.
    >
    >A point to a good article would be as good as a detailed explanation.


    Because mp3 is a highly compressed format and, although quality is
    surprisingly good, it isn't THAT good. Use a higher rate or, if you
    want to hear exactly what you recorded, use wav instead of
    compressing to MP3.

    CubaseFAQ page: http://www.laurencepayne.co.uk/CubaseFAQ.htm
  3. XODDI Guest

    Member Since:
    Message Count:
    0
    Re: OT: Why do I hear nasty audio artifacts in the high frequencieson .mp3 files? (the PHYSICS of it all)

    On Jun 22, 3:32 am, Laurence Payne <> wrote:
    > On Mon, 21 Jun 2010 13:06:02 -0700 (PDT), XODDI
    >
    > <> wrote:
    > >Mainly on material compressed at 128.

    >
    > >I do not think that it's just my ears, as other people I know have
    > >mentioned it.

    >
    > >A point to a good article would be as good as a detailed explanation.

    >
    > Because mp3 is a highly compressed format and, although quality is
    > surprisingly good, it isn't THAT good.  Use a higher rate or, if you
    > want to hear exactly what you recorded,  use wav instead of
    > compressing to MP3.


    Yeah, I do that.

    I was hoping to find out what happens - something like "the lower the
    bitrate, the less able the algorithm is to capture higher frequencies
    accurately because..." (I just made that up, BTW.)

    To me it sounds a lot like what happens when you use a bit reduction
    or waveshaping plug-in.

    Most folks just call it distortion, but inquiring minds got to know.
  4. Bogey Hempton Guest

    Member Since:
    Message Count:
    0
    Re: OT: Why do I hear nasty audio artifacts in the high frequencies on .mp3 files? (the PHYSICS of it all)

    I won't use anything but 320kbps on MP3's. Even those still sound like
    crap compared to the original wav or aif files.

    I don't know what the physics of it are or anything but I wish somebody
    would come up with an improvement over MP3 files.
    My heart just sinks when I finish a song in Cubase with all the
    dynamics on instruments like Omnisphere and Trillium, then you listen
    to the result after you've mastered it with T-Racks and converted it
    down to MP3.



    In article
    <>,
    XODDI <> wrote:

    > Yeah, I do that.
    >
    > I was hoping to find out what happens - something like "the lower the
    > bitrate, the less able the algorithm is to capture higher frequencies
    > accurately because..." (I just made that up, BTW.)
    >
    > To me it sounds a lot like what happens when you use a bit reduction
    > or waveshaping plug-in.
    >
    > Most folks just call it distortion, but inquiring minds got to know.
      • Advertising

Share This Page